NASEM Releases 4th Edition of “On Being a Scientist: A Guide to the Responsible and Ethical Conduct of Research”

Last month, the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine (NASEM) published an updated version of one of its most widely distributed consensus reports, On Being a Scientist: A Guide to the Responsible and Ethical Conduct of Research. Since its initial publication in 1989, the guide has helped graduate students and early career researchers navigate the complexities of an evolving research landscape while providing scholars with a clear framework for responsible, ethical research practices. The fourth edition, tackling issues such as global collaboration and emerging technologies, reflects the immense changes that have occurred within the scientific enterprise since the publication of the third edition in 2009.

NASEM convened an ad hoc committee to revise and expand the third edition of On Being a Scientist to better apply to the current research landscape. Alan Leshner, PhD, a physiological psychologist, co-chaired the committee and Barbara Means, PhD, an educational psychologist, also served. The committee also included Dena Plemmons, PhD, Chair of the Executive Board of the Association for Practical and Professional Ethics (APPE), who led a discussion on enhancing behavioral and brain research integrity at the 2024 FABBS Annual Meeting. 

Collaborating Responsibly

The first chapter of the report asks how researchers can effectively work together without compromising fairness, integrity, or the well-being of their team members. Over the last several years, scientists have shifted from treating research ethics as an individual responsibility to recognizing that the environment of a research team can either enable or hinder ethical behavior. For example, telling a graduate student to speak up about misconduct is not enough if the transgressor controls their funding, authorship opportunities, or career prospects. Additionally, when team members cannot question a senior colleague or report mistakes safely, it becomes incredibly easy for scientific errors and misconduct to go unchallenged, making this a quality concern as well. The report recommends several practices for building favorable conditions for ethical science and research integrity, including:

  • Establishing clear expectations early
  • Creating psychologically safe environments
  • Fairly recognizing contributions
  • Treating collaboration as an ongoing process
  • Immediately addressing power imbalances and harmful behavior

Earning and Maintaining Trust

The report goes on to discuss what makes researchers and scientific institutions worthy of public trust. Trust is essential to the functioning of the scientific enterprise, and findings may have limited influence if the public, policy makers, research participants, or other researchers do not trust the institutions producing that knowledge. The report argues that scientific credibility depends on demonstrating transparency, recognizing institutional responsibility, engaging the public meaningfully, respecting different communities, acknowledging past harms, and sharing benefits to make research findings useful. 

Openness and Security

The report then shifts from trust to security, asking readers how science can remain open and collaborative while also protecting sensitive information and guarding against the misuse of research. Scientific progress depends on sharing ideas, methods, data, and results; however, researchers also have the obligation to protect participants, sensitive information, intellectual property, and legitimate security interests. Responsible research requires balancing the values of openness and security, not choosing between the two. Excessive restrictions can inhibit scientific progress and collaboration, but inadequate security protections can expose participants to harm and allow research findings to be exploited. Responsible science requires context-specific judgement and a willingness to seek guidance as technology and geopolitical circumstances continue to change. The report outlines best practices on data governance, stewardship and privacy, the role of industry in research security, and the ethical issues surrounding emerging technologies. 

Responsible Conduct and Stewardship of the Research Process

The report concludes by discussing the responsibilities scientists have throughout the entire research process, from their first question to published findings. Stewardship is the ethical and effective management of people, resources, data, and public trust in the research enterprise, with the goal of advancing knowledge while safeguarding the integrity, accountability, and societal benefit of that research. It emphasizes that researchers’ ethical obligations do not end when they complete a study and publish results. Rather, scientists must remain accountable for the accuracy, transparency, and potential impact of their work. Furthermore, research is an iterative process, meaning new evidence can change what scientists understand and a willingness to correct earlier work is necessary for scientific responsibility. This is especially important for early career researchers who may feel pressured to avoid mistakes and protect their reputation. 

The fourth edition of On Being A Scientist reinforces longstanding principles of scientific integrity while simultaneously addressing a changing research landscape and providing new examples of ethical dilemmas researchers may encounter throughout their careers. Scientific progress does not just depend on the quality of research, but also on the integrity of the people, institutions, and practices behind it. This report brings collaboration, public trust, research security, and stewardship together into a unified framework, emphasizing that responsible researchers have an ongoing commitment to both scientific rigor and the overall public good. 

National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine (NASEM)